Social Policy Researcher Refutes One Nation Candidate's Migrant Welfare Claims

Social Policy Researcher Refutes One Nation Candidate's Migrant Welfare Claims

A leading Australian social policy researcher has challenged claims made by Katherine Deves, a One Nation candidate for the New South Wales Legislative Council, regarding welfare usage among overseas-born residents. Peter Whiteford, director of the Social Policy Institute at the Australian National University, stated that a chart shared by Deves on social media was misleading and contained incorrect figures.

Deves, a former Liberal Party federal candidate who recently joined One Nation, used the chart to advocate for substantial reductions in immigration. Speaking on ABC Radio Sydney, she asserted that up to 24 percent of individuals from certain overseas cohorts, specifically referencing Middle Eastern communities, were receiving government welfare benefits. She argued that these figures reflected significant pressure on national services, including housing, healthcare, education, and the National Disability Insurance Scheme (NDIS).

EXPERT REBUTS WELFARE GRAPH METHODOLOGY

The graph posted by Deves depicts working-age welfare recipient rates by country of birth, excluding the age pension, and attributes its figures to data from the Department of Social Services and the Australian Bureau of Statistics. The visual ranks individuals born in Sudan, Iraq, and Syria as having the highest rates of welfare dependency in the country, though it does not outline the methodology used to calculate these percentages.

Professor Whiteford criticized the graphic, noting that its data lacked clarity and context. He explained that higher rates of social security assistance among individuals from nations such as Syria, Iraq, and Afghanistan stem from their arrival under humanitarian refugee programs, which grant immediate access to the welfare system. Conversely, Whiteford highlighted that migrants arriving from countries such as India and China record lower rates of welfare utilization than the Australian-born population.

POLITICAL REACTION AND CONTROVERSY

During the broadcast, Deves also defended comments made by fellow One Nation candidate Stuart Bonds, who previously asserted at an anti-immigration rally that white Australians were undergoing demographic replacement. Deves rejected suggestions that the statement aligned with far-right conspiracy theories, arguing instead that rapid population growth driven by overseas-born residents represented unprecedented migration levels.

New South Wales Premier Chris Minns strongly condemned Deves's remarks, describing them as divisive. Minns defended the economic and social contributions of Middle Eastern Australians and migrant communities across the state, criticizing the candidate's rhetoric ahead of the upcoming March state election.

0 YORUMLAR

    Bu KONUYA henüz yorum yapılmamış. İlk yorumu sen yaz...
YORUM YAZ