European Commission Accused of Misleading Data to Disburse €2.5 Billion to Egypt
Leaked documents and deleted government data indicate that the European Commission approved €2.5 billion in macro-financial assistance loans to Egypt despite the country failing to expand its social welfare coverage as required by funding conditions. The EU disbursed the funds under a €7.4 billion strategic partnership agreement announced in 2024 by European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen and Egyptian President Abdel Fatah al-Sisi, aimed at supporting Egypt's economy, managing migration, and stabilizing the region.
The conditions for the soft loans required Egypt to increase recipient households under its Takaful and Karama cash transfer welfare initiatives. However, leaked records reveal that rather than expanding coverage by a targeted 160,000 households between 2024 and 2026, Egypt recorded a net decline of 85,734 households due to removals following a recertification process.
Welfare Data Discrepancies
To qualify for an initial €1 billion loan, Egypt was expected to add 100,000 households to reach 4.7 million beneficiaries. Confidential Commission documents described the objective as "broadly fulfilled," even though internal data showed a net loss of 62,281 households. For a subsequent €1.5 billion installment released in July 2026, the Commission marked a requirement to further expand the program by 60,000 households as "fulfilled," citing the addition of 442,118 families while omitting figures on removals. Data from Egypt's ministry of social solidarity—subsequently removed from its website—showed a net reduction of 23,453 beneficiaries in the 11 months leading up to June 2026.
To date, Egypt has received €3.5 billion of a planned €5 billion in soft loans under the multi-year package, with the remaining €1.5 billion scheduled before the end of 2027.
Reactions and Broader Scrutiny
Dutch MEP Tineke Strik announced plans to submit a formal inquiry demanding clarification from the European Commission, arguing that formal reporting obligations were treated as secondary to securing migration cooperation. Spanish MEP Sandra Gómez López called on the Commission to transparently explain its evaluation and prove that EU funds are enhancing social protections in Egypt. Timothy Kaldas of the Tahrir Institute for Middle East Policy also criticized the Commission's oversight regarding financial leverage for economic stability.
The financial disclosures coincide with heightened concern over press freedom and human rights in Egypt, highlighted by the detention and alleged abuse of six journalists from the investigative platform Matsadaash, as well as the recent court conviction of independent news editor Lina Attalah, who is currently appealing a one-year prison sentence.
0 YORUMLAR
Bu KONUYA henüz yorum yapılmamış. İlk yorumu sen yaz...